Caravan, Kiyui, Nanachi Trade Rewards in Made in Abyss Binary Star Falling into Darkness

Just a simple guide to tell what will you get for giving food to Mio in Caravan, Kiyui in Orphanage & Nanachi in her house.

The rewards you got from them is randomized so I’ll group them so easier to understand.

All food rewards (Mio & Nanachi) have 2 options of rewards that is Normal reward or Good reward but also can be fail which will not give you anything while Kiyui’s Stone rewards will never fails.

* Food is sorted by Crafting order

Mio’s Caravan Food

Mio’s food trade can be useful in early game if you want to stock up on antidotes or get some Mid-tier rations food.

You can easily guess the result from her expression too.

⭐Normal = Red Antidote, Blue Antidote, Paralysis Antidote

⭐⭐Good = Foreign Rations, Foreign Baked Sweets, Various Pickle Bottle

👎FAIL. She doesnt like it. You will not get anything in return

Simple hint:

• Cannot give food thats too simple or can be bought from the shop
• She doesn’t like any food with bug meat on it

Food	Reward
Cooked Insect	👎FAIL. She doesnt like it
Boiled Egg	❌Cannot be given
Cooked Tail Meat	⭐Normal
Cooked Fish	⭐Normal
Cooked Bird	⭐Normal
Soft-Cooked Meat	⭐Normal
Cooked Shellfish	⭐Normal
Cooked Meat	⭐Normal
Riko Bomb	⭐Normal
Fish Flake Onigiri	❌Cannot be given
Demonfish Miso Soup	⭐⭐Good
Gintoko Fish Soup	⭐⭐Good
Gintoko Meat Soup	⭐⭐Good
Gintoko Shellfish Soup	⭐⭐Good
Magotato (Granulated)	❌Cannot be given
Mustard Steamed Bun	❌Cannot be given
Crumbled Boiled Egg	⭐Normal
Steamed Bird	⭐Normal
Magotato Mochi	❌Cannot be given
Hard-Cooked Meat	⭐Normal
Survival Training Steak	⭐Normal
Cooked Shroombear Meat	⭐Normal
Salted Rare Fish Roast	⭐⭐Good
Laffi’s Special Lunch	❌Cannot be given
Netherworld Stew	👎FAIL. She doesnt like it
Mysterious Pot	👎FAIL. She doesnt like it
Rare Fish Hot Pot	⭐⭐Good
Beast Meat Pot	⭐⭐Good
Fish Pot	⭐⭐Good
Tail Meat Pot	⭐⭐Good
Bird Meat Pot	⭐⭐Good
Soft-Meat Pot	⭐⭐Good
Hard-Meat Pot	⭐⭐Good
Shellfish Pot	⭐⭐Good
Hamashirama Pot	⭐⭐Good
Gonkfish Liver	⭐⭐Good
Smoked Fish	❌Cannot be given
Smoked Demonfish	⭐⭐Good
Adult Onigiri	❌Cannot be given
Fried Magotato	❌Cannot be given
Fried Meat Platter	⭐Normal
Corpse Weeper Steak	⭐Normal
Pan-Fried Demonfish	⭐Normal
Fried Bird with Skin	⭐Normal
Rare Fish Sashimi	⭐⭐Good
Hamashirama Sashimi	⭐⭐Good
Seeker Camp Stew	⭐Normal
Riko Hodgepodge Stew	⭐Normal
Memorable Stew	⭐⭐Good
Gintoko Stew	⭐⭐Good
Hearthy Stew	⭐⭐Good
Lyza’s Cooking	⭐Normal
Gorgeous Hot Pot	⭐⭐Good

Kiyui’s Stones

Kiyui’s stones collection is not hard but can be tricky since the quest marker wont always shown up.
The easiest way to trigger it is bring some stones in your inventory and talk to him in Shiggy’s room.

*Extra info: Shiggy sometimes gives you side quest to hunt certain creature or show him certain relic if you talk to him.

The stone trade can be useful since kiyui can give you Limber Scales which only can get from fishing or 5th Layer Jellyfish drops. And very easy since you can just give him Flash Stone from 2nd layer or Electric Stone from 3rd layer for good rewards.

Kiyui only gives 2 option either he likes the stone or not.

⭐Normal = Fishing Baits (Shrimp, Small Fry, Lugworm)

⭐⭐Good = Shellfish Shell, Limber Scales, Insect Exoskeleton

Simple hint:

• He likes sparkling stones

Stone	Reward
Hard Rock	⭐Normal
Flash Stones	⭐⭐Good
Electric Stones	⭐⭐Good
Incediary Stones	⭐Normal
Explosive Stones	⭐Normal

Nanachi’s Food

After meeting nanachi, She can either give you quest to gather some resource for her cooking or ask for food.

The only way to trigger it is visit her and she can only give either quest once per abyss dive.
Trading the food can be important since you can get Orb Piercer Antidote and the Tokajishi Charm (Special) which is special accesory for Orb Piercer poison resist, also to get the Nnaaa… achievement from Nanachi.

Or simply just to get some Grade 2 or Grade 1 relic easily.

⭐Normal = Orb Piercer Antidote, 4th Grade Relic, 3rd Grade Relic, Tokajishi Charm

⭐⭐Good = Tokajishi Charm (Special), 2nd Grade Relic, 1st Grade Relic

👎FAIL. She doesnt like it. You will not get anything in return

Food	Reward
Cooked Insect	⭐Normal
Boiled Egg	⭐Normal
Cooked Tail Meat	⭐Normal
Cooked Fish	⭐Normal
Cooked Bird	⭐Normal
Soft-Cooked Meat	⭐Normal
Cooked Shellfish	⭐Normal
Cooked Meat	⭐Normal
Riko Bomb	⭐Normal
Fish Flake Onigiri	⭐Normal
Demonfish Miso Soup	⭐⭐Good
Gintoko Fish Soup	⭐Normal
Gintoko Meat Soup	⭐Normal
Gintoko Shellfish Soup	⭐Normal
Magotato (Granulated)	⭐Normal
Mustard Steamed Bun	⭐Normal
Crumbled Boiled Egg	⭐Normal
Steamed Bird	⭐Normal
Magotato Mochi	⭐Normal
Hard-Cooked Meat	⭐Normal
Survival Training Steak	⭐Normal
Cooked Shroombear Meat	⭐Normal
Salted Rare Fish Roast	⭐⭐Good
Laffi’s Special Lunch	⭐⭐Good
Netherworld Stew	👎FAIL. She doesnt like it
Mysterious Pot	⭐Normal
Rare Fish Hot Pot	⭐⭐Good
Beast Meat Pot	⭐Normal
Fish Pot	⭐Normal
Tail Meat Pot	⭐Normal
Bird Meat Pot	⭐Normal
Soft-Meat Pot	⭐Normal
Hard-Meat Pot	⭐Normal
Shellfish Pot	⭐Normal
Hamashirama Pot	⭐⭐Good
Gonkfish Liver	⭐Normal
Smoked Fish	⭐Normal
Smoked Demonfish	⭐Normal
Adult Onigiri	⭐Normal
Fried Magotato	⭐Normal
Fried Meat Platter	⭐⭐Good
Corpse Weeper Steak	⭐⭐Good
Pan-Fried Demonfish	⭐⭐Good
Fried Bird with Skin	⭐⭐Good
Rare Fish Sashimi	⭐⭐Good
Hamashirama Sashimi	⭐⭐Good
Seeker Camp Stew	⭐Normal
Riko Hodgepodge Stew	⭐Normal
Memorable Stew	⭐⭐Good
Gintoko Stew	⭐Normal
Hearthy Stew	⭐⭐Good
Lyza’s Cooking	⭐Normal
Gorgeous Hot Pot	⭐⭐Good

Hope this is useful.

If you don’t get what you want for the reward, you can always load save data and retry give the reward again, it will get randomized again.